Kehoe introduces LJ Cove seal bill

State Sen. Christine Kehoe introduced a bill Friday to make seal habitation a permissible use at La Jolla’s Children’s Pool.

She made the Feb. 27 deadline for introducing new legislation. Her bill came in response to San Diego City Council’s 7-1 vote Feb. 17 to enlist the support of the legislature in shifting the battlefront in the skirmish over the presence of harbor seals from local courts to Sacramento.

District 1 Councilwoman Sherri Lightner cast the lone dissenting vote.

“We understand the City Council’s desire to seek legislation that will allow them a little more flexibility in deciding how to treat Children’s Pool and the seals that are beaching there,” Kehoe said after the council’s vote. “We want bipartisan support.”

Kehoe’s bill, SB 428, is coauthored by Assemblywoman Lori Saldana of the 76th District and Assemblyman Nathan Fletcher of the 75hth District representing La Jolla.
An excerpt of SB 428:

” … those tide and submerged lands are required to be devoted exclusively to public park, bathing pool for children, parkway, highway, playground, and recreational purposes, and for other uses that may be incidental to, or convenient for, the full enjoyment of those purposes. This bill would include in that list of uses and purposes a marine mammal park for the enjoyment and educational benefit of children.”

Amending the trust
Attorney Paul Kennerson – who represents Valerie O’Sullivan in her lawsuit against the city claiming the seals’ presence violates the trust’s terms – wasn’t happy with the city’s action and filed a motion attempting to block it.

“There’s a lot of legal authority that a public entity trustee of a public trust cannot attempt to change a public trust,” he argued. “The courts say the act of even attempting it is beyond their powers.”

Kennerson’s motion was denied Feb. 20.

“The judge did not agree with his idea that a trust cannot be changed by the legislature,” City Attorney Jan Goldsmith said following the hearing.
The tide in the courts had clearly been turning against seal advocates and in favor of Kennerson and his client, with judges holding for the sanctity and inviolability of the trust.

On other fronts
Meanwhile, the city has been making substantial progress under a court order to do an environmental impact report and obtain other necessary permits to ultimately dredge sand from the pool, which has been fouled by seal waste, to clean and restore it for human use.

Goldsmith, a former state assemblyman, said after the council’s vote that legislation for Children’s Pool is being sought, not to decide how the beach should be used, but to avoid further costly litigation by the city.

“I wanted it to get out of the courts and lawyer’s fees and endless litigation that kept going on,” he said, “and get it into the hands of the legislators who have the power to end all this.”

Costs still rising
Goldsmith noted the city ‘s costs for litigation and environmental permitting for Children’s Pool well exceed $1 million and are rising. He added it could take as little as six months for legislation on the pool to be passed in Sacramento.

The net effect of its passage, he said, would be to “change the terms of the trust to render the current lawsuits moot.”

At the Council hearing on seals, Lightner expressed uncertainty over the appropriateness – and wisdom – of pursuing a legislative remedy for Children’s Pool.

“Do we know the risks of this course of action?” she asked. “My concern is that the attempt to make the litigation go away will be more costly than completing the EIR and abiding by the court order.”

Related posts:

  1. Holiday closures
  2. Goldsmith unseats Aguirre as S.D. City Attorney
  3. Artificial reef to replenish beach at Fletcher Cove
  4. SD Council members: No more VIP boxes
  5. Bill Hoffman takes business, humor seriously

Short URL:

Posted by on Feb 26, 2009. Filed under Archives. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6






  • Kent Farrington and Blue Angel to compete at inaugural Longines Los Angeles Masters
    Rancho Santa Fe resident Robin Parsky’s Blue Angel and top world-ranked rider Kent Farrington will participate in the inaugural Longines Los Angeles Masters at the Los Angeles Convention Center Sept. 25-28. More than 25 of the best horse-rider combinations will compete for $1 million in prize money. […]
  • Survey shows community doesn’t support bond for new Rancho Santa Fe School gym at this time
    The Rancho Santa Fe School District has received the results from its community interest survey on the possibility to rebuild the school gym. At a July 21 special board meeting, Superintendent Lindy Delaney reported that 54.3 percent of the community is not interested in supporting a bond on the November ballot at this time. “The results showed us the intere […]
  • Fire sprinkler extinguishes garage fire
    On July 24, at 2:02 a.m., firefighters from the Rancho Santa Fe Fire Protection District responded to a residential fire in the 10000 block of Lone Dove Street in 4S Ranch. When they arrived on scene, firefighters found that a single sprinkler head had activated and extinguished a fire in the garage near the water heater. One person was home at the time and […]