Mount Soledad cross case back in court

The most recent legal skirmish in the 20-year battle over the constitutionality of the Mount Soledad Korean War Memorial cross began Wednesday in Pasadena as a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral arguments from attorneys on both sides.

The case is an appeal of a federal court decision in San Diego that allowed the cross to remain on its La Jolla mountaintop memorial site. It’s not clear when they will rule.

Plaintiff’s attorney James McElroy, representing Jewish War Veterans who are challenging the cross’s constitutionality, said he felt opening day went well.

“The three judges are very experienced in separation of church and state issue,” he said. “They asked very intelligent questions.”

Asked whether he was optimistic about the outcome, McElroy said, “The law is pretty clear. Every 9th Circuit decision involving a Latin cross on permanent land has come out the same way: We expect to prevail.”

Cross advocate Charles LiMandri, an attorney for the conservative Christian nonprofit Thomas More Law Center, agreed the 9th Circuit has shown a preference against the cross remaining in place, but disagreed on the case’s final outcome.

“I’m not confident they (the appeals court) will get it right,” he said. “But I’m very confident the U.S. Supreme Court will.”

Though the U.S. Supreme Court declined once before to hear the Soledad cross case, LiMandri said the situation is different now.

“The U.S. Supreme court declined to hear the case years ago because it was involved with the state constitution,” he said. “It’s a different situation now. It’s on federal land.”

In 2006, the war memorial cross site was transferred by Congress from the city of San Diego to the federal Department of Defense. It is now under the auspices of Commander, Navy Region Southwest in San Diego.a

McElroy concurred that the circumstances of the case have changed over the years, but claims the core legal issues on which it’s being decided remain the same.

“The real question is, is that cross primarily a religious symbol, or is it primarily a veterans memorial?,” he asked. “Obviously, it’s primarily a Christian symbol. If it’s a Christian symbol, its unconstitutional for it to be on government property.”

Related posts:

  1. CA Supreme Court upholds Prop 8
  2. Toll road issue likely to end up in federal court
  3. Outgoing Padres owner to appear in court next week
  4. Superior Court to close on Wednesday
  5. American Red Cross announces critical blood supply need

Short URL:

Posted by on Dec 9, 2009. Filed under Archives. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • New Rancho Santa Fe Library Branch Manager welcomes community input
    Rancho Santa Fe Library’s new Branch Manager Haley Kwon has been charmed by the village’s “sweet, down-home” character, the simple pleasure of visiting the local library and people’s enjoyment of a slower speed of time. “It’s a small town and the library is a place for people to connect,” Kwon said. “People have a different sense of time here, they come in t […]
  • Robotics booming at Rancho Santa Fe School
    By Karen Billing At R. Roger Rowe School, 44 percent of first graders are participating in the robotics program this year. The school is fielding 44 robotics teams, including 31 percent of second grade, 23 percent of third grade, 35 percent of fourth grade and 39 percent of fifth grade. In the middle school, there are two FIRST LEGO League (FLL) teams and fi […]
  • Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices honored with Stevie Gold Award
    Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices was recently named Startup of the Year in the 2014 American Business Awards, earning the brokerage the Stevie Gold award. The award was presented at the Fairmont Millennium Park Hotel in Chicago, Illinois. “Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices is among a select few organizations to be entrusted with the Berkshire Hathaway name,” co […]