ONE VIEW: A parable in three acts

By Gordon Clanton
North Coastal columnist
A young basketball coach took his first job at a small college. Moving into his office, he found on his desk three sealed envelopes and a note from his predecessor that read: “If things go badly, open one envelope at the end of each season.”

The first season was a disaster, so the young coach opened the first envelope and found a note that read: “Blame me.”

So the coach blamed his predecessor: “How could anyone be expected to win with the team I inherited?” His critics were sympathetic, and he was not fired.

The second season was not much better, so the coach opened the second envelope and found a note that read: “Blame the alumni.”

So the coach blamed the alumni: “How could anyone be expected to win with so little support?” His critics were persuaded, and he was not fired.

The third season also ended badly. Seeking solace, the coach opened the third envelope and found a note that read: “Prepare three envelopes.”

After three bad years, it’s time for the Del Mar Union School District board majority to prepare three envelopes.

Like a moth to a flame, I am again drawn to comment on the dysfunctional board. As with a gory roadside accident, I cannot look away. Like Lot’s wife, I must look back.

In 2006, dissident board member Annette Easton teamed with Katherine White and Steven McDowell to win control of the board. In 2008, the new majority fired the superintendent, Tom Bishop, at a buyout cost of about $285,000. In March 2010, the board fired the superintendent they hired, Sharon McClain — settlement pending. It’s hard to put a price on the damage done to the reputation of the district.

Critics say the district is in chaos. The board micromanages district affairs, drives away some of its best people and dithers on key strategic decisions. Public board meetings are tedious and interminable. After campaigning on a promise of “transparency,” the board majority has done much of its business in secret.

Knowing Del Mar and Carmel Valley as I do, I am confident that able candidates will step up to recapture the board for the community. The filing period for the November election runs from July 12 to Aug. 6, plus five more days if none of the incumbents seeks re-election.

Gordon Clanton teaches sociology at San Diego State University. He welcomes comments at

Related posts:

  1. Can Rodriguez restore the board?
  2. Attorneys for former Superintendent McClain send letter to school board
  3. What has posterity ever done for me?
  4. Candidate filing period for county, state elections open
  5. Trustees’ View: Redirecting your federal stimulus could help schools

Short URL:

Posted by admin on Jul 15, 2010. Filed under Archives, Columns, Editorial Columns, One View. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6






  • Horizon Prep in Rancho Santa Fe graduates from cottages to new campus building
    Horizon Prep dedicated five new grammar school classrooms on Monday, Aug. 25. Donor contributions have allowed the Rancho Santa Fe school to grow from 14 little green cottages to a school with 29 state-of-the-art classrooms and more to come. “We couldn’t be more excited about the opening of this school year,” said Dr. Bob Botsford, Horizon Prep president and […]
  • Rancho Santa Fe Republican Women to present candidates forum
    The Rancho Santa Fe Republican Women, Fed., members will present Republican candidates for federal, state and local races at their “Best Party in Town” event from 3-5 p.m. Sunday, Sept. 21, at the Morgan Run Resort & Club. The candidates have been invited to speak and meet with the voters. Cost is $25; light refreshments will be served. Please send check […]
  • Rancho Santa Fe Library to present Alzheimer’s series
    Taking aim at Alzheimer’s, the county Board of Supervisors in May launched the Alzheimer’s Project, an effort to create a regional strategy to improve caregiver resources and to support research efforts to find better treatments and ultimately, a cure for the disease. […]