Taking the other side on MLPA fight

Carl Lind
La Jolla resident

Eric Brickenstein’s Community View column (Good reasons to back marine protection act, July 15) appears to be derived from emotion rather than logic and serious science. To understand the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) it is important to know that it is primarily a political creation. It was vetoed by Gov. Pete Wilson on its first attempt at passage, but approved on its second attempt the following year when Gray Davis took office. Both votes were largely along party lines.

Although the MLPA did not mandate additional “no-take” fishing reserves, powerful research institutions and the animal rights lobby have used their resources to exploit this legislation in an attempt to ban sport fishing in about 20 percent of California coastal waters.

One motivation is the millions of dollars in potential grants for studies of proposed new ocean reserves. Because of California’s failing economy, such funds are desperately needed by research organizations. Closure activists often argue that the “oceans are in crisis.” That is almost certainly true near some third world countries where explosives and poison are sometimes used to capture fish in their local reefs, but ocean waters along the California coast have been — and continue to be — very well managed by the state’s Department of Fish & Game using traditional marine management techniques.

No-take reserves are not a legitimate marine management tool. They actually prohibit management! A boundary is established in an ocean area, and whatever happens within that area — is allowed to happen. It is a Utopian, “nature knows best” approach that ignores real dangers to our environment. One only has to see the hordes of sea lions along San Francisco’s waterfront, damaging boats and docks, eating marine resources and polluting the water to understand this.

All cities without MLPA reserves now have the right, under the federal Marine Mammal Protection Act, to remove nuisance marine mammals. San Francisco occasionally exercises this right to dissuade these animals.

Why would any coastal city willingly give up its option to control nuisance animals by acquiescing to MLPA no-take reserves? Various La Jolla swimming beaches, for example, are now being being threatened by expanding populations of harbor seals and sea lions. With the implementation of no-take reserves in these areas, any discouragement of these animals will be illegal within the reserves. Additionally, removal of, say, jellyfish and kelp piles below the mean high tide line will be prohibited.

Despite claims to the contrary, there is no scientific proof that no-take marine reserves significantly improved the marine environment. As leading scientists have pointed out, almost any change in the marine ecology could be contributed to many factors (e.g., water temperature, pollution, disease, storm conditions, out of control sea urchin or pinniped populations, etc.). Because of these variables, replications of experiments are often impossible.

For transparency’s sake, I must add that I’m an active fisherman — often fishing several times a week along our coast. My view of local fishing opportunities is opposite that of Mr. Brickenstein. That said, the amount of fish I catch in a year is probably eaten in one day by a decent sized sea lion.

Bottom line: The current Fish & Game rules I must follow are strict, fair and effective. Let’s not take the great sport of surf and kayak fishing away from our youth because of an ill-conceived idea such as the MLPA.

Related posts:

  1. MLPA panel decision due Nov. 10
  2. Proposals for MLPA include Del Mar
  3. Council backs third MLPA option
  4. SD doesn’t take position on MLPA proposals
  5. Marine scientists’ revelations require action

Short URL: http://www.delmartimes.net/?p=7242

Posted by on Jul 23, 2010. Filed under Archives. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6



  • La Jolla Library welcomes new chief Shaun Briley
    For La Jolla Riford Library’s new head librarian, Shaun Briley, books have been a part of his life and career, in some form or another, every step of the way. […]
  • Tangerine trees, marmalade skies for Beatles-inspired Patrons of the Prado gala in Balboa Park, San Diego
    “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds” was the theme of the Patrons of the Prado gala on July 12, 2014 in Balboa Park, San Diego. Beatles-inspired music came from Wayne Foster Entertainment. Sandy Redman and Jeanne Jones served as event chairs. 2014’s beneficiaries are the Reuben H. Fleet Science Center, San Diego Museum of Art and The Old Globe Theatre. […]
  • La Jolla’s Best Bets for events July 31- Aug. 7
    Museum of Photographic Arts (MOPA) offers a crash course in starting a photography collection 6 p.m. Thursday Aug. 7. at the Ligne Roset Showroom, 7726 Girard Ave. MOPA assistant curator Chantel Paul and director of jdc Fine Art Jennifer DeCarlo will share professional insights. […]




  • Rancho Santa Fe resident’s Gen 7 wines earn top honors
    Rancho Santa Fe resident Tim Bacino’s Gen 7 Wines is on a hot streak, his varietals winning several awards this summer in California wine competitions. […]
  • Torrey Pines High School baseball alum Taylor Murphy excelling in pro ball
    It was during a breakout senior year at Torrey Pines High that Taylor Murphy first popped up on the radar of professional scouts. Shortly after graduation, Murphy was selected by the San Diego Padres in the 40th round of the June 2011 amateur draft. He declined, honoring a commitment to the University of the Pacific. Three years later, Murphy got another sho […]
  • Why Hire a Licensed Landscape Professional?
    By Steve Jacobs, Nature Designs The old saying – “if something seems to good to be true, it probable is” – is quite fitting when it comes to hiring a contractor for your home or yard construction project. While it is smart to shop around, get quotes, etc., don’t fall into the trap of trusting […]