Not a dime’s worth of difference?

By Gordon Clanton
North Coast columnist

A growing number of “independent” voters hold that there is no meaningful difference between Democrats and Republicans. I disagree. Democrats favor progressive taxation. Republicans favor huge tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans.

Gordon Clanton

Democrats support Social Security, Medicare, and national health insurance. Republicans want to repeal these programs. Theirs is a faith-based health system, a single-prayer plan.

Democrats are pro-labor. Republicans are anti-union.

Democrats seek to raise the minimum wage. Republicans usually vote NO.

Democrats are pro-choice. Republicans, that odd coalition of the very rich and the religious right, have pledged to outlaw abortion and stem-cell research.

Democrats are friends of the environment. Most Republicans oppose measures to protect the natural world.

Most Democrats oppose the death penalty. Most Republicans support it.

Jerry Brown and legislative Democrats favor a mix of tax extensions and spending cuts to balance the California budget. Every legislative Republican insists on an all-cuts budget, no matter what the cost to schools, parks, roads, cops, and the poor, sick, and elderly.

Most Democrats favor comprehensive immigration reform with a pathway to citizenship — and they supported the Dream Act. Many Republicans are immigrant-bashers. Pete Wilson and Brian Bilbray come to mind.

In the 1960s, Democratic Presidents Kennedy and Johnson led the charge for black civil rights. Republicans promptly launched a “Southern Strategy,” designed to appeal to disgruntled white people.

As the Great Depression was brought on by the policies of Republican presidents Harding, Coolidge, and Hoover, the great recession of our own time was brought on by the policies of Republican president George W. Bush.

Throughout the Great Depression and beyond, voters elected Democrat Franklin Roosevelt four times and gave him large majorities in Congress.

Voters did NOT say in 1936: “Well, FDR hasn’t ended the Depression yet. I guess we should give control of the economy back to the Republicans.”

Consider the company you keep if you believe there is no difference between the parties. George Wallace, racist governor of Alabama and “state-rights” candidate for the presidency, was fond of saying, “There’s not a dime’s worth of difference between the Democrats and the Republicans.”

Ross Perot made the same claim in 1992, with the unintended consequence of helping Bill Clinton defeat Bush I.

The same argument was made by Ralph Nader, whose third-party run in 2000 cost Al Gore the presidency (despite winning the popular vote) and ushered in eight years of Bush II.

Suggestion (from Andy Borowitz) of a campaign slogan for possible presidential candidate Rick Perry: “What harm could a governor of Texas do?”

Gordon Clanton teaches Sociology at San Diego State University. He welcomes comments at

Related posts:

  1. Gap between registered voters closing
  2. Primary election post-mortem
  3. SD representatives’ house health care vote sticks to party lines
  4. Primary election kaleidoscope, II
  5. Primary election kaleidoscope

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Jul 3, 2011. Filed under Opinion. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

3 Comments for “Not a dime’s worth of difference?”

  1. Vince Hall

    Well said Gordon! But in my experience those who say "there's no difference between the parties" are simply making lame excuses for their own willful ignorance and political apathy. They are equally prone to such cop-outs as "you can't fight City Hall," "my vote doesn't count," and "they're all corrupt." These people have never contacted their representatives, usually can't even name them, and they complain about how long the ballot is…all while watching an average of 35 hours per week of television. Some of our nation's founders doubted ordinary people could be trusted to responsibly participate in governance. Today's slackers, who hide behind empty cliches, lend credibility to those fears.

  2. richard

    But the Democrats ALWAYS LOSE. The Democrats are the good cop to the Republicans bad cop. They've been losing policy battles consistently for 30 years, always after a noble and well-publicized fight. Beginning to look a bit suspicious.
    If you were Big Biz, and you decided you were going to take over the country and needed to get into politics, would you stop at buying just one party? Hell, there are only two, and they are cheap! An entire election cycle, including all candidates for all parties in all national offices, including the president, spent around $2 billion before Citizens United, maybe, what, twice that now. Exxon made some $45 billion profit last year. If it was just Exxon, that would be a hell of an investment. But with all corporations chipping in, it's peanuts.
    What would have then? A government exactly like what we have now, where big business always wins and the public good always loses.

  3. Middy McModerate

    Yeah, this article is not slanted AT ALL. Is this what passes for journalism anymore?

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • Rancho Santa Fe Rotary Club to present second ‘Taste of Rancho Santa Fe’
    The Rancho Santa Fe Rotary Club continues to live up to the motto, “Service Above Self,” and invites you to partner with the Rotary Club at the 2nd Annual Taste of Rancho Santa Fe on Oct. 12. Guests of the event, to be held from 4-7 p.m., will have an opportunity to stroll through the historic and iconic grounds of The Inn at Rancho Santa Fe while sampling f […]
  • Melodrama to open at Village Church Community Theater in Rancho Santa Fe
    As part of the Rancho Days celebration in Rancho Santa Fe, “The Saga of Sagebrush Sal, A Comedy Western Melodrama” is set to open Oct. 5 at the Village Church Community Theater. In this old-fashioned comic melodrama, Sagebrush Sal decides to take over the busiest establishment in town, The Bloody Turnip Saloon, which is owned by Jake the Snake. The audience […]
  • Rancho Santa Fe Historical Society acquires Covenant founder’s ledger
    The Rancho Santa Fe Historical Society has acquired the ledger of Barton Millard, which dates back to the 1920s, and will unveil it at Coffee On The Patio Saturday, Sept. 20, at 10:30 a.m. at La Flecha House. Millard was a founding member of the Rancho Santa Fe Association, co-wrote the initial CC&Bs, and served four terms as its president. Millard’s gra […]