Carmel Valley officials stunned by impediment to Pacific Highlands Ranch development

By Karen Billing
Staff Writer

Members of the Carmel Valley Community Planning Board said they were “blindsided” by city staff last week when they were told that Pacific Highlands Ranch (PHR) would not be able to build past its 1,900 development units until SR-56 was widened.

The news especially came as a shock after the group worked with city staff for months last year to prepare Proposition C, which untied PHR’s development from the SR-56 and Interstate-5 interchange project. Proposition C passed with 70 percent of the vote, allowing PHR to work on getting the facilities it is lacking, such as parks, shopping, library, trails and recreation facilities.

“We wouldn’t be where we are now without the passage of Prop C,” said Frank January, a project manager for the facilities financing section in the city’s department of development services (DSD). “This is another issue that has come up right behind it.”

“Prop C removed one transportation issue, this is another one that has always been there,” said Tom Tomlinson, also a project manager in the same department.

Tomlinson said that the development restriction is in Pacific Highlands Ranch’s transportation financing plan. Development is capped at 1,900 units until SR-56 is widened from four to six lanes from the I-5 interchange to one mile east of Carmel Valley Road.

Prop C was a fix for Prop M, which imposed a restriction endorsed by surrounding community members in Carmel Valley to ensure that PHR was a self-sustaining community. When PHR appeared to stagnate under the restrictions, there was a call by the same Carmel Valley community to right the wrong through Prop C.

The SR-56 widening restriction is not a “politically-based threshold” like Prop M’s was, but instead is in place to mitigate the impacts of traffic, Tomlinson said.

Carmel Valley planning board vice chair Manjeet Ranu was working with city staff on a facilities phasing plan on the Prop C Working Group when the issue was brought to his attention. He and planning board chair Frisco White said it seems unacceptable that this was never brought up during the process of preparing Prop C and only brought up now at the 11th hour after a citywide vote.

The working group was scheduled to meet with DSD staff this week to discuss next steps.

It might be a possibility to look at the last traffic study and transportation phasing plan to see if there have been changes and if the restriction can be amended. Ranu said the mayor’s office would be looking into the matter.

“There’s more questions than answers right now,” Tomlinson said. “The Prop C Working Group is frustrated because they thought they got over the main hurdle and now they’ve found there’s another one we need to address.”

Related posts:

  1. Prop. C key ballot for Pacific Highlands Ranch, Carmel Valley
  2. Council OKs 27-acre Pacific Highlands Ranch development
  3. Prop. D, changing Pacific Highlands Ranch restrictions, passes
  4. Pacific Highlands Ranch ‘frozen in time?’ Board hopes to spur growth
  5. Speak up now on plan for Pacific Highlands Ranch core

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Aug 10, 2011. Filed under Carmel Valley, News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

1 Comment for “Carmel Valley officials stunned by impediment to Pacific Highlands Ranch development”

  1. Dennis Ridz

    During discussion with Caltrans subcommittee on the I5/Sr-56 Connectors, it was made very clear by Caltrans that the SR-56 Connectors had to be built before SR-56 would be expanded to 6 lanes. So why is this 'new' issue being raised after the approval of Prop C that SR-56 needs to be expanded before Pacific Highlands Ranch can move forward. It appears that someone in our Councilmembers office failed to understand the facts or failed to work closely with Development Services. This 'new' information should have been disclosed as part of the Prop. C literature.

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • New Rancho Santa Fe Library Branch Manager welcomes community input
    Rancho Santa Fe Library’s new Branch Manager Haley Kwon has been charmed by the village’s “sweet, down-home” character, the simple pleasure of visiting the local library and people’s enjoyment of a slower speed of time. “It’s a small town and the library is a place for people to connect,” Kwon said. “People have a different sense of time here, they come in t […]
  • Robotics booming at Rancho Santa Fe School
    By Karen Billing At R. Roger Rowe School, 44 percent of first graders are participating in the robotics program this year. The school is fielding 44 robotics teams, including 31 percent of second grade, 23 percent of third grade, 35 percent of fourth grade and 39 percent of fifth grade. In the middle school, there are two FIRST LEGO League (FLL) teams and fi […]
  • Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices honored with Stevie Gold Award
    Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices was recently named Startup of the Year in the 2014 American Business Awards, earning the brokerage the Stevie Gold award. The award was presented at the Fairmont Millennium Park Hotel in Chicago, Illinois. “Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices is among a select few organizations to be entrusted with the Berkshire Hathaway name,” co […]