Clanton’s analysis simplistic, generalizes

By Mark A. Peter

I would like to address Professor Clanton’s editorial and his response to Tim Binder’s letter to the editor. Although sociology and political science do have some overlap, I think that someone with greater expertise needs to address these issues. Professor Clanton is wrong in his contention summarized by the cliche “Not/more than a dime’s worth of difference.” His analysis is simplistic and commits the fallacy of generalization. If you look at the two major parties’ platforms, of course they are different. But in reality this is not the case. A more correct distinction is establishment vs. conservative or liberals.

Firstly, let us look at social issues: Pro-life: There are a number Democrats who are pro-life, it isn’t exclusively a Republican issue. VP Gore was pro-life as a Congressman, as was Senator Bill Bradley. Some Republicans support homosexual civil unions as does President Obama.

Fiscal issues: The house has many Blue Dogs who are fiscally conservative and even support a more conservative social agenda. Republican Senators Spector, Lincoln and Chaffey to name a few support a liberal agenda. Conservatives complained that President Nixon gave the rhetoric to conservatives and action to the liberals. Former Governor and Vice President Nelson Rockefeller was also a liberal on many issues. Mayor Rudy also fits this category on many issues. Mayor Ed Koch was conservative on several issues. Governor Mitt Romney has flip-flopped and, at times, was more liberal than Sen. Ted Kennedy. His successor Sen. Scott Brown is a conservative on some issues and others a liberal. Gov. Schwarzenegger in many ways was more of a Kennedy liberal. President Bill Clinton would put his finger to the wind and support whatever was popular (welfare reform, etc.). President George W. Bush enacted many liberal acts such as No Child Left Behind (authored by Ted Kennedy), prescription drugs, greater spending, banking bailout, etc. His father was also liberal in many respects. Former Senator Dole and current Senators McCain and Graham have sided with Democrats on several issues. Now let me correct some factual errors.

Republicans do not oppose the environment. Teddy Roosevelt created many national parks. They support a responsible policy that’s not extremist. They are not immigrant bashers. They support immigration as long as it’s legal. They want the law to be enforced. Review your history and you will find that Democrats opposed Civil Rights legislation and it was up to the Republicans to pass it. Abraham Lincoln, who was the first Republican, enacted the Emancipation Proclamation. President Coolidge oversaw great economic growth, as did JFK and Reagan. Many of FDR’s New Deal proposals were declared unconstitutional and so he tried to pack the court. His policies prolonged the Great Depression and it was the full economic mobilization for WW II that brought us out. Gov. Wallace repented of his racist attitudes and went to many black churches apologizing.

Americans are tired of the Repucrats and their hold on the political process. Many are looking for those who offer a real choice and alternative to the two major parties as evidenced by the candidacies of Perot, Nader and Buchanan.

Mark A. Peter teaches English and debate in E. Asia. He has taught U.S. government and U.S. history at the high school level. He has also completed studies in law and human rights. He has been a volunteer for presidential and gubernatorial, congressional and senatorial campaigns.

Related posts:

  1. More than a dime’s worth of difference
  2. Not a dime’s worth of difference?
  3. Not a dime’s worth of difference?
  4. Gap between registered voters closing
  5. Not a dime’s worth of difference? — Revisited

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Aug 24, 2011. Filed under Letters, Opinion. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • New Rancho Santa Fe Library Branch Manager welcomes community input
    Rancho Santa Fe Library’s new Branch Manager Haley Kwon has been charmed by the village’s “sweet, down-home” character, the simple pleasure of visiting the local library and people’s enjoyment of a slower speed of time. “It’s a small town and the library is a place for people to connect,” Kwon said. “People have a different sense of time here, they come in t […]
  • Robotics booming at Rancho Santa Fe School
    By Karen Billing At R. Roger Rowe School, 44 percent of first graders are participating in the robotics program this year. The school is fielding 44 robotics teams, including 31 percent of second grade, 23 percent of third grade, 35 percent of fourth grade and 39 percent of fifth grade. In the middle school, there are two FIRST LEGO League (FLL) teams and fi […]
  • Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices honored with Stevie Gold Award
    Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices was recently named Startup of the Year in the 2014 American Business Awards, earning the brokerage the Stevie Gold award. The award was presented at the Fairmont Millennium Park Hotel in Chicago, Illinois. “Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices is among a select few organizations to be entrusted with the Berkshire Hathaway name,” co […]