County leaders keep high-speed rail on the table, despite conflicting views

By Claire Harlin

Contention regarding a high-speed rail vote came somewhat as a surprise to local leaders from Solana Beach and Del Mar at a San Diego Association of Governments Board Meeting (SANDAG) on Dec. 9, and the neighboring cities stand at polar ends of the discussion.

A grouped measure involving three items failed a board vote, but because it seemed the regional leaders on the board were focusing their disapproval on only one issue — the renewal of a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between regional stakeholders and the California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA) to cooperate on a plan that would connect the state’s major metropolitan areas via high-speed rail — SANDAG officials decided to conduct votes on the three issues separately. This decision, along with a changed voted from El Cajon Mayor Mark Lewis, kept the MOU alive and the voice of the SANDAG board (as well as other regional associations of government) from being taken totally off of the table.

Solana Beach City Councilwoman and SANDAG board member Lesa Heebner, who was mayor at the time of the meeting, said what happened at the meeting was “mind-boggling” and that she didn’t expect the item to be as long and controversial as it was.

“Discussion got going about some thinking this is never going to be done,” Heebner said. “However, to kill or not to kill the whole project was not before us. Yet, it was directed in that way by some of the members of the board.”

She said a “no” vote on the MOU would mean “having no voice any longer on whatever happens.”

Referencing the fact that the area between San Diego and Los Angeles has the second-highest number of train commuters in the nation (next to the Northeast Corridor that carries commuters between Boston and Washington D.C.), she said it’s important that our region be in on the conversation — even though connecting L.A. and San Diego is only in the second phase of the 800-mile project.

“We’ve proven we can put people on these trains,” she said. “Wouldn’t we want to be at the table?”

Del Mar Mayor and SANDAG board member Carl Hilliard, who was deputy mayor at the time of the meeting, was one of almost half the board who voted against extending the MOU to send a message to the CHSRA. The memorandum was set to expire at the end of 2011, so the close vote extended it until December 2016.
He called the proposed high-speed rail, which has soared in estimated construction cost from $33 billion to at least $98 billion, “the train to nowhere.”

“It’s a huge boondoggle,” said Hilliard, who was voted in as mayor on Dec. 12. “The most heavily traveled corridor isn’t on the planning stages, but what is on the planning stages is from Merced to Bakersfield. Nobody wants to go from Merced to Bakersfield.” The California High-Speed Rail Authority wants to begin work next year on the length of track between those two Central Valley cities.

Hilliard said that the CHSRA has already spent $800 million in tax dollars and hired 20 public relations firms, as well as political consultants.

“We don’t need to be paying these people huge salaries to plan for something that’s never going to happen,” he said, also pointing to the hefty salary of CHSRA Chief Roelof van Ark. According to a 2010 L.A. Times article about his appointment, van Ark earns $375,000 a year.

According to a poll released earlier this month by Field Research Corp. in San Francisco, 64 percent of those surveyed want another public vote on the project since it has risen in cost, and that 59 percent of respondents would oppose it.

At the recent SANDAG board meeting, grouped with the original vote involving the MOU was also the option of sending a letter to CHSRA regarding the authority’s new high-speed rail business plan, published in November, wherein the higher construction costs were presented.

The SANDAG board voted in favor of sending its comments to the state authority.

Charles “Muggs” Stoll, SANDAG’s director of land use and transportation planning, said there will be a wide range of comments, including the fact that the board is disappointed that San Diego is only in the second phase of the project when it is an important feeder area to both Orange County and Los Angeles. He said there is a push to make the lower San Diego corridor (LOSSAN), which extends from Orange County to downtown San Diego, the best “feeder route” it can be. There will also be feedback regarding the dramatic increase in projected construction costs.

“The more we can invest into that corridor, the more we can build a market here of people riding from San Diego to L.A.,” he said.

Related posts:

  1. High-speed rail plans to be discussed
  2. High-speed rail on agenda
  3. Sanders: City stands ‘firmly behind high-speed rail’
  4. State agency rallies support for high-speed train
  5. Public provides input on high-speed rail

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Dec 27, 2011. Filed under Del Mar, News, Solana Beach. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

3 Comments for “County leaders keep high-speed rail on the table, despite conflicting views”

  1. Derek

    "Del Mar Mayor and SANDAG board member Carl Hilliard… called the proposed high-speed rail, which has soared in estimated construction cost from $33 billion to at least $98 billion, 'the train to nowhere.'"

    By comparing apples with oranges (a price in 2008$ with a price in YOE$), he conclusively demonstrated that he doesn't really understand the high speed rail project. Therefore, he should be ignored, and kicked off SANDAG.

  2. DavFlo

    This HSR is a boondoggle, and nothing else. The greatest and most expensive fleecing of the taxpayer in World History. The "current" HSR estimate to build is $98.5 to 118 Billion, up from the $33 Billion sold to voters – or "lowballed" to them – in 11/08. That's a 150% increase in construction costs in 3 years, and which doesn't even include the costs to build San Diego and Sacramento lines (which the 11/08 ballot proposition said WAS INCLUDED as part of the $33 Billion).

    So, extrapolating out the 150% increase ever 3 years from now until 2032, when the CAHSRA moved out the completion date to, means the train WILL EVENTUALLY COST $22 TRILLION DOLLARS TO COMPLETE (NOT INCLUDING SAN DIEGO OR SACRAMENTO!). Proof here: . If that same 150% increase occurs every three years, from now until 2032 (the revised completion date) then HSR will ultimately cost: $100, $243, $497 (billion), $1.47, $3.62, $8.92, $21.96 Trillion dollars. Yes, it’s ridiculous to expect 150% increases every three years, but it’s also ridiculous to take needed books and school supplies, art classes, music programs, etc. from K-12 children in exchange for an out of control HSR spending boondoggle. Democrats must kill the Train now.

  3. Despite the fact that these products are clearly labeled as harmful, you may not be able to keep them away from
    the hands of your children completely. bank by assets, reported that its first half costs at a unit holding some
    of the lender”. Keep your medication safely out of the reach of your cat.

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • Alumni and Advancement Center named for longtime supporters Larry and Cindy Bloch of Rancho Santa Fe
    The University of Rochester’s Alumni and Advancement Center in Rochester, N.Y. has been renamed the Larry and Cindy Bloch Alumni and Advancement Center in recognition of the couple’s support of the university and, in particular, its Advancement programs. In a ceremony on Wednesday, Oct. 15, UR President Joel Seligman formally dedicated the center in honor of […]
  • RSF Association Board Biz: It’s fire season: Be prepared
    The Rancho Santa Fe Fire Protection District (RSFFPD) was officially formed in 1946, in the aftermath of a devastating fire that took place in 1943 and destroyed brush, farmland and homes from Rancho Bernardo through Rancho Santa Fe, all the way to Solana Beach and Del Mar. Today the Fire District spans 38 square miles and protects nearly 30,000 residents. W […]
  • Rancho Santa Fe couple lead way in helping those with thyroid disorders
    Few people may know that Graves’ disease is one of the most common autoimmune diseases afflicting Americans today. Fewer still may know that the only national non-profit dedicated to its patients is headquartered in Rancho Santa Fe. The Graves’ Disease and Thyroid Foundation, co-chaired by Rancho Santa Fe residents Kathleen Bell Flynn and Steve Flynn, has be […]