The right pension facts

By Carl Hilliard
Del Mar mayor

Recently the U-T San Diego castigated Del Mar for unaddressed and unfixed pension issues.

Carl Hilliard

Granted the U-T based its “Shame on the Cities That Won’t Fix Pensions” editorial on incorrect information from the San Diego County Taxpayers Association (SDCTA). But when the SDCTA sent a correction, the U-T did not print a retraction or my clarifying response.

The SDCTA’s correction acknowledged that Del Mar’s increase is only 5.79 percent for FY 2011 to 2012 – a very low increase necessitated by lower investment earnings on CalPERS’ assets over which we have no control.

As a member of CalPERS, the state’s defined-benefit retirement program funded through employee and employer contributions, and investment earnings on system assets, our contribution is based on projected actuarial cost. Del Mar has not increased employee wages enough to increase those actuarial costs.

CalPERS voted to lower its projected rate of return on investments from 7.75 to 7.50 percent, increasing Del Mar’s annual contributions from $56,130 to $99,540. Alarmingly, the true internal CalPERS’ rate of return is 5 to 6 percent so unless the fund improves performance, there will be further increases.

Another inaccuracy in the U-T editorial stated that Del Mar does not have a second-tier pension contribution for new hires. We do, implemented July 1, 2011 for fire and to go into effect July 2, 2012 for miscellaneous classifications.

We have instituted other pension cost savings, as well. We were one of the first cities to require employees to contribute the full employee contribution (8 percent for general employees). In October 2010, fire safety employees began contributing the entire 9 percent share, and by 2013, lifeguard employees will be contributing their entire employee contribution.

While the same SDCTA study lauded other cities for reducing pension-system costs, the U-T failed to add that some of those cities had, just prior to the review, a structural deficit with expenses greater than revenues. In order to balance the budget as required by law, those cities cut payroll by eliminating staff positions. Reducing salaries to balance budgets decreases pension costs.

We didn’t do that and just as much to the point, Del Mar has a balanced budget with surplus reserves plus a coveted Standard & Poors’ AAA bond rating. We do not pay big salaries or pensions to city employees.

Del Mar has done everything right. The U-T cartoon about Del Mar ignoring pension obligations could not be more wrong.

Related posts:

  1. City of Solana Beach, employees come to terms on wages, pension cuts
  2. Carmel Valley will be helped by pension and retiree healthcare reform, councilman says at workshop
  3. SD firefighters lose pension case
  4. Firefighters union loses suit over pension benefits
  5. Solana Beach water district board asks staff to research cost savings

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Apr 5, 2012. Filed under Columns, Editorial Columns. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • Rancho Santa Fe Golf Club Ladies Golf Tournament to raise funds for breast cancer research
    October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month, and the women of the Rancho Santa Fe Golf Club have organized an annual tournament for 13 years raising funds for organizations whose focus is the treatment and/or cure and prevention of breast cancer. Deana Ingalls and a capable and creative committee are organizing another Breast Cancer Benefit Tournament on Oct. 1 […]
  • Couple pleads guilty in fraud case involving Rancho Santa Fe broker
    A real estate investor and his wife pleaded guilty Sept. 30 to conspiring with a Rancho Santa Fe broker and others to defraud mortgage lenders and impede the Internal Revenue Service. Grant McCollough, 38, and his 36-year-old wife, Marisa, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud and defrauding the United States. Both face up to five years in prison […]
  • Village Church Installation of Rev. Dr. Neal Presa
    An installation of the Rev. Dr. Neal Presa, one of the Associate Pastors of the Village Church, was held Sept. 28 […]