Prop 34: Death knell for death penalty in California?

I have long been opposed to the death penalty.  Capital punishment (such a euphemism!) is cruel, unusual and arbitrary, yet it does not deter violent crime.  States with the death penalty have higher murder rates than states without it.  And capital punishment falls disproportionately on the poor and people of color.

The death penalty is irreversible. If the state executes an innocent person there is no redress — a concern made more acute as DNA evidence exonerates more of the wrongly convicted.

The death penalty is enormously expensive, because the mandatory appeals procedures cost more than life imprisonment.  California spent $4 billion to administer capital punishment over the past 33 years – more than $300 million per execution.

Furthermore, when the state executes criminals, the state models the very behavior it is attempting to prevent.  We must stop killing people to demonstrate that killing people is wrong.

American support for the death penalty is in sharp contrast with a global trend toward its abolition.  A 1980s attempt to bring back the death penalty in Great Britain was decisively defeated.  Canada abolished capital punishment in 1976, Australia in 1985.  The European Union made the abolition of the death penalty a condition for membership.

Conversely, consider the nations where the death penalty routinely is employed: Iran, North Korea, Syria, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, China, Cuba under Castro, Haiti under the Duvaliers, the old Soviet Union, South Africa before the end of apartheid.  In a global context, strong support for the death penalty puts the United States in pretty bad company.  And within the U.S., the states with the most executions are the states with the most lynchings a century ago.

Support for the death penalty in California has dropped after peaking at about 80 percent in the 1980s.  But even then, about half would abolish capital punishment if those who commit especially heinous crimes were imprisoned for life with no possibility of parole.

A 2009 poll showed that most Californians would support a sentence of life without parole rather than the death penalty for those convicted of murder.  If the life sentence was combined with a requirement that the inmate work to make restitution to the family of the victim, only 26 percent of Californians would opt for the death penalty.

Proposition 34 on the November ballot proposes exactly that: It abolishes the death penalty, but assure that those who commit the most horrible crimes be imprisoned for life without parole and be required to make restitution.

Gordon Clanton teaches Sociology at San Diego State University.

He welcomes comments at

Related posts:

  1. Suspects in professors death could get death penalty
  2. Moe Dubois blames legal system for daughter’s death
  3. Report: Gardner violated parole seven times
  4. State halts shredding of parole records
  5. Carmel Valley’s “Fugitive Mom” released from prison

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Jul 26, 2012. Filed under One View. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6





  • Community input received on proposed health club and pool facility in Rancho Santa Fe
    About 100 Rancho Santa Fe residents showed up on Friday, Oct. 17, for a health club and pool community meeting, the last outreach before ballots were mailed on Monday, Oct. 20. On the ballots, members are being asked whether the Rancho Santa Fe Association should spend $350,000 on a professional planning phase for the potential new community amenity. RSF Ass […]
  • Czech violin duo to perform at Village Church in Rancho Santa Fe
    In cooperation with the Consulate General of the Czech Republic, the Czech School San Diego hosts a free classical violin concert by internationally recognized Czech violin player Jaroslav Svecený and his daughter, Julie Svecená, who are on a tour of the United States. The concert will be at 7 p.m. Oct. 27 in the Village Church. The father-daughter duo will […]
  • Rancho Santa Fe weekly sports update
    Torrey Pines defeated Canyon Crest Academy 4-3 in a Palomar League opener for both teams on Oct. 9. Alayna Tomlinson and Farah Farjood each scored two goals to lead the Falcons. Samantha “Sammy” Cirino added one goal and one assist. […]