Intense emotions are distorting clear thinking

By Richard Levak

Dr. Bierman’s response to my letter suggesting “fear of change” could be a factor in the opposition to Prop. J was instructive of the opposition’s perspective. He begins with a reasonable assertion that suggesting fear as a motivator unfairly prejudices the opposition’s perspective. Fair enough. However, he reveals in the same sentence and throughout his letter the opposition’s belief in the moral superiority of their perspective. His implied request for linguistic reasonableness is absent when he describes the Prop J supporters as holding “specious arguments” and “foisting changes” on, what he later says, is a “quiet and persistent majority.” “Foisting?” Really Dr. Bierman? Over 90 public meetings is hardly “foisting.” What makes you presume you are in a majority? Remember that an election will decide the “majority” and neither side has been quiet! The sentiment of the opposition, that Prop J is “top down” and has been forced on them and that they are a “quiet and persistent majority” with “common sense” is well expressed in his letter that started as a criticism of presumptiveness but quickly became judgmental and highly presumptive. How can he call the engineers “bungling” when he suggested “fear of change” was presumptive! The good doctor’s letter could not better reveal that intense emotions are distorting clear thinking.

Related posts:

  1. Fear of change has nothing to do with opposition to Prop J
  2. Opinion/Letters to the Editor: Traffic impacts clear
  3. Don’t let Del Mar decline, vote ‘Yes’ on Prop J
  4. ‘Just Say No’
  5. Pro Prop J rhetoric divisive, distorted

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Oct 30, 2012. Filed under Letters, Opinion, Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply



Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6



  • FRONTLINE CANCER: Exercise, exercise, exercise!
    Regular exercise improves health in ways most of us already know. It helps control weight, maintain strong bones, muscles and joints, reduce the risk of heart disease, diabetes and premature death. Exercise quite literally makes us feel better, physically and mentally. […]
  • Hunger Games in the Real World
    At age 6, Nya, a girl living in San Diego, was suffering from malnourishment because her father, a single parent was struggling to raise (and feed) his children on an $11-an-hour job. For long periods of time their cupboards were bare, and Nya, who is now 18, subsisted on a diet of ramen noodles and free lunches provided by her charter school. She was in cri […]
  • Fall brings the call to learn something new
    Local gems like UCSD Extension, Osher Lifelong Learning, La Jolla Community Center and La Jolla Library all offer a variety of opportunities for personal growth — and all welcome newcomers. […]